Li Ziyin, Ni Jun. Objective quality assessment for enhanced chromatic images[J]. Journal of Image and Graphics, 2015, 20(5): 643-651.DOI: 10.11834/jig.20150507.
Objective quality assessment for enhanced chromatic images
Image enhancement is very important in various visual signal processing applications. In many applications
such as photo retouching
visual inspection
and machine analysis
image enhancement methods are proposed to obtain images with better visual quality. In these cases
original images are usually not “perfect.” However
existing full-reference image quality assessment methods use “perfect” original images as reference signals to assess image quality. Therefore
existing full-reference image quality assessment methods cannot be used to evaluate the visual quality of enhanced images. In this paper
a novel visual quality assessment metric based on features of gradient
colorfulness
and luminance is proposed for enhanced chromatic images. The human visual system (HVS) is highly sensitive to gradient information
which can effectively capture both contrast and structural/texture information. Thus
in the proposed metric
a gradient enhancement map is calculated by estimating the enhancement degree of the enhanced image compared with its reference image. In addition
colorfulness is the attribute of the perceived color in certain regions appearing to be more or less chromatic. In the proposed metric
the colorfulness of an enhanced image is estimated by two factors
namely
one is the average distance from different colors to the center gray and the distance between individual colors in the image. Consequently
a colorfulness enhancement map is computed by calculating the enhancement extent of color saturation and its standard deviation. Meanwhile
luminance enhancement factor is integrated together based on the analysis that the luminance change would influence the appearance of gradient and colorfulness information. Moreover
the gradient and colorfulness features of the reference images are extracted to build the objective quality assessment metric for enhanced images. Finally
the model of the relationship between the luminance enhancement factor and the gradient/colorfulness enhancement map is built. The proposed metric is compared with the existing image quality assessment metrics
including the peak signal to noise ratio (PSNR)
structural similarity (SSIM)
visual information fidelity (VIF)
most apparent distortion (MAD)
appearance-based MAD (MADa)
and augmented MADa (dxMADa). Three evaluation criteria are used for performance evaluation
a good image quality assessment (IQA) metric has high PLCC and SROCC values and a low RMSE value. In our proposed metric
compared with the best available metric for enhanced images
PLCC and SROCC improved 2.9% and 2.5%
respectively. Moreover
RMSE reduced 12.3%. In sum
the proposed metric is an obvious improvement than existing metrics when assessing enhanced images. In the proposed metric
gradient and colorfulness enhancement maps can accurately calculate the enhancement extent. By integrating the luminance enhancement estimation and features in the reference image
the proposed metric can perform better than other existing metrics. The proposed metric provides an objective score for enhanced images and solves two problems
namely
the reference images of enhanced images are not “perfect” images and similarity measure algorithms cannot be used well for enhanced images. We have conducted experiments to demonstrate the performance of the proposed metric for enhanced images. We have conducted the experiments to demons trate the performance of the proposed metric for enhanced images.